The debate about whether abortion is justified

The novelty of the present debate is that the positive position shall be taken by a secularist, whom I presume shares many assumptions in common with me, in particular some physicalist account of mind and existence, and a nontheological understanding of morality and law.

Debate: Abortion

I think I have clearly established a framework to view this debate, clearly defined what it means to be ethically justified, and shown that abortion cannot be ethically justified.

The baby was not going to survive, he argued, and a chemical abortion now could prevent the need for a surgical procedure later. During the second half of pregnancy, the pregnancy can often be ended prematurely by inducing labor and using aggressive neonatal care to sustain the life of the child outside the womb.

Also, the final product must be completely and fully justified after all reasoning is deciphered. Next you say "This can be broken down into two parts: A murderer of one person is no less a murderer if he allows thousands to live, nor even if he saves thousands from dying.

One act of violence or sexual assault against an innocent person is not remedied, but rather, compounded by another act of violence against another innocent person. However, there may be indirect harm caused by abortion.

A fetus not feeling pain is a reason why abortion could be allowed, but it is not a reason why it is justified. If you have an ectopic pregnancy, you will need quick treatment to end it before it causes dangerous problems. Many Personhood leaders do not believe that the goal of their Amendment is to overturn Roe v.

Abortion debate

Since division of the zygote into twins through the process of monozygotic twinning can occur until the fourteenth day of pregnancy, Kenny argues that individual identity is obtained at this point and thus abortion is not permissible after two weeks.

What say does he have.

Are There Rare Cases When an Abortion Is Justified?

These observations must be kept in mind throughout this debate. Nevertheless, it is in this month that a complex cerebral cortex, the one unique feature of human--in contrast with animal--brains, begins to develop, and is typically complete, though still growing, by the sixth month.

If you can, give the little guy or gal a chance. In their Answers magazine, Dr. Or, does the fetus have a right to life that is binding on the woman and her body and that outweighs any rights held by the woman, requiring her to give birth.

A fetus can no more feel pain than a surgical patient under general anasthesia, or a paraplegic whose lower-body nerves continue reacting to stimuli, but cease sending signals to the brain. We would instead merely create an identical twin inside a used body, with an infantile mind and no memories, no complex personality traits, and no intellectual skills.

If you wanted to argue from the other angle you could say that eating anythig lving is bad, which is just ridiculous. Regardless, several large studies have confirmed that expectant management may allow spontaneous regression of the tubal ectopic pregnancy the vast majority of the time.

Technically, abortion is illegal during the last trimester of pregnancy, unless it threatens the "health" of the mother.

It is always wrong to kill one innocent human being to alleviate the suffering of another human being. Are there circumstances in which a woman cannot be said to be responsible for her own impregnation, such as failed contraception or rape.

Based on the above, it follows that some things could be "immoral" for some people and "moral" or amoral for others, since people vary in their values.

Debate: Abortion

Is it profit for the providers. From now on, when I employ the term "moral" or its cognates, I am referring to this universal truth, and not to the equally true but necessarily parochial principles found everywhere in human society.

MY opponent has not given me any info as to when a fetus can be concieved as actually living. At the LEAST its not possible to say you're ethically justified in ignoring the negative thing which occurred, just as you cannot say that a woman is ethically justified in having sex and then aborting the child because she has no moral obligation to keep it.

But this value system would only exist for them, not for others. Before sorting through the ethics of the matter, we would do well to first lay out some context: Either the patient had twins, one in the fallopian tube and one in the uterus, or the fallopian tube pregnancy unattached and reattached in the uterus.

Although this fresh brain would be ready to learn and develop anew, it would be a different person. A Pro-Life Rebellion is Afoot There is a pro-life rebellion afoot that is distinguishing itself from the mainstream pro-life movement and is indicting it for complicity in the Abortion Holocaust.

An abortion at this stage is clearly a very different affair than at later stages. December Fetal pain, its existence, and its implications are part of a larger debate about abortion.

Even if we were able to regenerate a brain-dead patient's cerebral cortex, using the genetic blueprint in her cells, we would still fail to resurrect her. Wade struck down state laws banning abortion in A human being is something of great moral significance, and therefore we should give the fetus importance for its ability to develop.

People’s personal feelings about abortion have always dominated the debate, and I get it: abortion is a more emotional issue than, say, descaling the kettle.

Is abortion justifiable? Asked by: GOP. Add a New Topic; Add to My Favorites Debate This Topic to decide whether or not to give birth or to abort. However, abortion should only be limited to those that I've listed above simply for the fact that it's our responsibility to account for our actions and handle such decisions to have sexual.

The Guardian - Back to home. Whether you’re pro-choice or not, the abortion debate is not about you What the abortion debate needs is empathy, not narcissism –.

Is abortion ever justified? If not, why? If it depends, then on what? The main debate is whether abortion is moral or immoral. One of the great things about being human is to have individual thoughts and opinions.

More about Essay about Is Abortion Ever Justfied? Abortion Words | 8 Pages; Abortion Syndrome and Legalized Abortions. The main debate is whether abortion is moral or immoral.

One of the great things about being human is to have individual thoughts and opinions. That is something that will never change. Even put aside all the debate about rights and freedom of choice. You don't even need that argument to address this debate heading.

It's actually quite common for normal pregnancies to go awry and for the prospective parents waiting eagerly for their baby to find out it.

Abortion: Morally Permissible? The debate about whether abortion is justified
Rated 4/5 based on 97 review
Debate: Abortion - Debatepedia